|
WORKSHOP |
IL CANCRO DELLO STOMACO |
|||
|
|
Histogenesis of cardiac carcinomas compared to distal gastric carcinomas. |
|||
|
|
Department of Pathology - University Hospital Maastricht - The Netherlands |
|||
|
Messina |
Gastric
cancer is one of the most common malignancies in the world: it is the second
cause of cancer mortality worldwide [1]. Epidemiological studies however have
shown that the incidence rates of gastric cancer are declining in U.S.A. and
Western-Europe [2, 3].
This evolution is predominantly due to a decreasing incidence of antral cancer,
although some studies have shown that diffuse tumours of the corpus have also
been declined in frequency [4]. Synchronous with the decline of distal gastric
cancer, the incidence rates of cardiac cancer
have dramatically increased in U.S.A., up to 4 – 5 % annually [5, 6].
However the increasing trend for cardiac adenocarcinomas varied in function of
the age: below 65 years the prevalence of this type of carcinoma increased with
20 %, whereas above the age of 65 years the increase was 60 % [7]. In parallel
with the increase of cardiac adenocarcinomas, the incidence of oesophageal
adenocarcinomas is rising at an alarming rate as a result of which the incidence
of oesophageal adenocarcinoma is higher than the incidence of oesophageal
squamous carcinoma in the U.S.A. [7]. In contrast to distal gastric cancer,
where there is no gender predominance, cancers of the cardia predominantly
affect white males; a feature which also is observed in oesophageal
adenocarcinomas [7,8]. Compared to distal gastric cancer, cardiac cancer has
an even worse prognosis. This bad prognosis is related to the advanced stage of
disease at the time of presentation: T1 lesions are significantly less commonly
diagnosed in the cardia than in distal gastric cancer [9]. Moreover a higher
incidence of regional lymph nodes and hepatic metastases is found in association
with this type of cancer [10]. The different evolution in incidence rate as well
the differences in clinical features suggest that distal gastric cancer and
cardiac cancer are two distinct entities.
According
to Correa gastric carcinogenesis is a multistage model, in which the development
of the intestinal type of gastric cancer begins with the induction of a chronic
inflammation. This inflammatory process, which is strongly related to a
Helicobacter pylori infection, leads to the development of atrophy and
intestinal metaplasia. Due to the chronic inflammation damage will occur to the
genome of cell, resulting in dysplasia and finally in to an invasive neoplastic
process or carcinoma. This sequence is not only determined by the presence of
Helicobacter pylori, but is also dependent on the characteristics of the host
and other environmental factors [13]. Until the discovery of Helicobacter pylori
in 1983 by Marshall et al., the role of these environmental factors have been
considered to be very important [14]. Multivariate analysis, performed in the
study of Hansson et al., has shown that low fruit intake, smoking, high alcohol
and coffee consumption increase the risk for gastric cancer (OR 1.7-10.5) [15].
Antioxidants, such as vitamin C, reduces the risk for gastric cancer by
approximately one half [16]. Nowadays
there is no doubt that the risk for gastric cancer is influenced primarily by
the presence of Helicobacter pylori. Hence the World Health Organization’s
International Agency for Research on Cancer has classified this micro-organism
as a group I or definite carcinogen (IARC) [17]. In
a meta-analysis performed on the pooled data of the three most important
prospective studies, Helicobacter pylori infection gives an almost nine-fold
increased risk of cancer [18]. This risk is
dependent on the age of acquisition of a Helicobacter pylori infection as in
young adults the relative risk is nine times higher than in elderly people [19].
Besides the age, microbial virulence factors as well as the host response
to the organism will determine the outcome of the colonization. Type 1 strains,
which are cagA- and vacA-positive strains, are more virulent strains, inducing a
more pronounced inflammatory response and an increased risk for distal gastric
cancer, in particular intestinal type of cancer [20-22]. The
risk for gastric cancer is also dependent on the topography of the chronic
inflammation. Populations with a predominant antral gastritis have a lower risk
than those with a pangastritis [23]. The explanation for this phenomenon is the
atrophy of the corpus, induced by the chronic Helicobacter pylori related
inflammation, resulting in a hypochlorydia or achlorydia. Due to the high pH the
stomach will be colonized by other bacteria, producing carcinogenic products,
namely N-nitroso compounds. The carcinogenic effect of these products has been
confirmed in animal models [24]. Several cohort studies have shown that the
annual incidence of atrophic gastritis is 1 up to 3 % [25, 26].
In parallel with the development of atrophy, the gastric foveolar
epithelium will be replaced by another well-differentiated intestinal-type
epithelium. This phenomenon, named intestinal metaplasia, may however occur
independently of the process of atrophy. The annual incidence of intestinal
metaplasia in association with an atrophic gastritis is around 7 % per year
[26]. Atrophy as well as intestinal metaplasia are both precancerous lesions,
associated with an increased risk for an intestinal type of distal gastric
cancer. Whereas according to Sipponen et al. the gastric cancer risk increases
up to 18-fold in the presence of atrophic gastritis, the odds-ratio for gastric
cancer is 3.8 in the presence of type III intestinal metaplasia in a population
from Slovenia [27, 28].
Other studies however could not confirm that this subtype of intestinal
metaplasia, also named type IIb or colonic-type of intestinal metaplasia, is
associated with an increased risk for gastric cancer. In these studies the
presence of type III intestinal metaplasia was related to the age of the
patients, as it was more prevalent in elderly patients [29]. This well-established sequence of events holds through
for the intestinal type of cancer only. The histogenesis of diffuse type
carcinoma is less well understood. According to the hypothesis of Sipponen et
al. this type of cancer originates from a non-atrophic chronic gastritis [30].
Other studies propose that a normal mucosa or dysplastic non-metaplastic
structures or hyperplastic foveolar structures are the origin of this tumour
[31-33].
In
contrast to the numerous data, concerning the etiopathogenesis of distal gastric
cancer, the histogenesis of cardiac adenocarcinomas is less clear. The
development of cardiac carcinoma is presumably also a stepwise organized process,
in which environmental factors are involved [34]. These environmental factors
are similar to those in case of distal gastric cancer, be it that the
relationship between smoking and the risk for cardiac cancer is stronger
[35-37]. Similar to the development of distal gastric cancer, the histogenesis
of cardiac cancer begins with a chronic inflammation of the cardia, which gives
rise to the presence of intestinal metaplasia. Conflicting data however have
been published concerning the etiopathogenesis of carditis. Several studies
identified a relationship between carditis and gastroesophageal reflux. In these
studies carditis is considered to be a better histological marker for
gastroesophageal reflux disease than reflux oesophagitis [38, 39]. In contrast
other studies considered carditis as an extension of a Helicobacter pylori
related pangastritis to the most proximal part of the stomach [40, 41]. The
prevalence of Helicobacter pylori in carditis varies between 10.9 % and 95 %
[39, 41]. Although Genta et al. showed that the prevalence of Helicobacter
pylori in the cardia is similar to the antrum, the meta-analysis of Huang et al.
could not confirm that the presence of these micro-organisms increases the risk
for cardiac cancer [19, 42]. Moreover the study of Chown et al. has shown that
colonization with the more virulent strains, namely CagA+ strains, is associated
with a reduced risk for cardiac cancer [43]. In the study of Voutilainen et al.
however carditis was related to Helicobacter pylori as well as gastroesophageal
reflux, be it that the association with Helicobacter pylori was more obvious
[44]. In
our multicenter study, performed on a study-population of oesophageal (n = 133,
mean age 63 yrs, M/F-ratio = 6), cardiac (n = 109, mean age = 64 yrs, M/F-ratio
= 3.95) and distal gastric cancer (n = 100, mean age 68 yrs, M/F-ratio = 1.4),
we have observed a significant difference in chronic gastritis in corpus
biopsies. Whereas the prevalence of chronic inflammation in oesophageal
adenocarcinomas is 36 %, a significant higher prevalence of chronic gastritis is
observed in association with cardiac adenocarcinomas (56 %) (p < 0.01), be it
that this is still significantly lower than in case of distal gastric cancer (88
%) (p < 10-6). In our study the presence of chronic gastritis is
Helicobacter pylori-related with a prevalence of respectively 23 %, 33 % and 73
% in oesophageal, cardiac and distal gastric cancer [45, 46]. Intestinal
metaplasia, which prevalence at the normal squamocolumnar junction varies
between 9 and 31 %, is related to Helicobacter pylori or gastroesophageal reflux
[41, 43, 47, 48].
Several studies have indicated that Barrett’s oesophagus, which is due to
gastroesophageal reflux, may be the precursor of cardiac adenocarcinomas. In
these studies the prevalence of Barrett’s oesophagus, which is mostly a short
segment Barrett, is around 42% [46,
47]. This observation however could not be confirmed in other studies [51, 52]. In
literature conflicting data have been published concerning the histogenesis of
cardiac carcinomas, which may either be related to a Helicobacter pylori
infection or gastroesophageal reflux. Epidemiological as well as histological
data suggest that cardiac adenocarcinomas may be related to either distal
gastric cancer or oesophageal cancer. The lack of clarity in the current data
may possibly be due to the different definitions of cardiac adenocarcinomas,
applied in the literature [53-55]. Molecular
data, concerning the histogenesis of cardiac carcinomas, are limited and do not
solve this problem. Microsatellite
instability, which results from the inactivation of mismatch repair genes and
occurs in around 30 % of the gastric cancer, is more prevalent in cardiac
adenocarcinomas according to the study of Lin et al. [56]. This observation
however could not be confirmed in the study of Keller et al. [57]. Flow
cytometric analysis has shown that cardiac adenocarcinomas appear to have the
highest DNA aneuploidy rate of nearly 100 %, compared to distal gastric tumours
[58]. During the inflammatory response polymorphonuclears produce free oxygen
radicals, which may damage the DNA of cell. As a result the function of tumour
suppressor genes or proto-oncogenes may become disturbed. The p53 gene, situated
on the short arm of chromosome 17, is a tumour suppressor gene, which encodes a
protein, playing a essential role cell cycle regulation and tumour suppression
[59]. The prevalence of p53 gene mutations, which is mostly situated in the
exons 5 to 8, varies in function of the gastric cancer subsite and the phenotype.
p53 mutations are more frequent in cardiac cancers (54 %) than distal gastric
cancers (25 %), and are more frequently associated with intestinal type gastric
cancer [60]. Whereas the study of Strickler et al. shows a comparable number of
p53 mutations in cardiac as well as distal gastric cancer, other studies showed
that these mutations are as common as in oesophageal carcinomas [61-63].
Comparative genomic hybridisation has shown that chromosome 5q (DCC), 17 p (p53)
and 18q (APC) loci are important in the carcinogenesis of
oesophageal, cardiac as well as distal gastric cancer. However molecular
analysis does not show consistent differences in function of the localisation of
the tumour. Comparative
genomic hybridisation of oesophageal and cardiac adenocarcinomas reveals
identical genetic patterns in these two groups with few exceptions [64, 65].
Similar genetic abnormalities may be found in distal cancer, be it that the
prevalence of these can vary [66].
Based
on the current, sometimes contradictory, scientific data it is not possible to
classify cardiac carcinomas definitively as being either of oesophageal or
gastric origin. As already mentioned, these conflicting results in the studies
are possibly due to the different definitions of the cardiac adenocarcinomas
applied [53-55]. Therefore a clear definition of a cardiac adenocarcinoma has to
be defined in order that the population of cardiac tumours will be more
homogenous. Recently a commentary on ‘an uniform use of the
TNM-classification’ is published, in which advices are given concerning the
classification of gastroesophageal tumours as being of oesophageal or gastric
origin [67].
1.
Parkin DM, Pisani P, Ferlay J: Estimates of the
worldwide incidence of eighteen major cancers in 1985. Int
J Cancer 1993;54:1-13.
|
|||
|
A cura di: Unità di Chirurgia Endoscopica - Ospedale Piemonte - Messina |
||||
|
© |
||||